Home

Prolog resolution

Suppose we have the following knowledge base:

f(a). 
f(b). 

g(a). 
g(b). 

h(b). 

k(X) :- f(X), g(X), h(X).

How does Prolog determine whether k(Y) is true (provable)? That is, how does Prolog determine the value for Y that makes the query true?

Its search process can be see in this graphic. The process is as follows:

  1. Create a temporary variable _G34 (randomly-named) to stand in for Y. This is an implementation detail, so that if some other rule uses Y (a completely different variable), then the variable names don't collide.
  2. The goal is to prove k(_G34). To do so, proving f(_G34), g(_G34), h(_G34) will be enough. This is the new goal.
  3. To satisfy the first part of the new goal, f(_G34), the knowledge base is searched. There is no rule for f/1 (the predicate with arity one) but there is a fact: f(a). The first matching fact/rule is tried first. Thus, _G34 gets set to a (from unification).
  4. Now, g(a), h(a) is the new goal. g(a) is satisfied just fine, because exactly that term is found in the knowledge base (trivial unification).
  5. Now, h(a) is the new goal. But, nothing in the knowledge base unifies with h(a) and there is no h/1 rule, so there is a problem.
  6. Go to the last decision point. This was when _G34 was set to a. Try to set it to something else. f(b) is in the knowledge base as well, so go with _G34 = b.
  7. The new goal is g(b), h(b), etc… (which ultimately works).

prolog-resolution-ex1.png

Now we'll switch to this knowledge base:

loves(vincent, mia).
loves(marcellus, mia).
jealous(A, B) :- loves(A, C), loves(B, C).

How does Prolog find the proof for jealous(X, Y), and what values do the variables take?

The proof tree is shown below. Note that there are four smiley-face leaves in the tree. This means there are four different ways to get a proof, which means there are four different sets of variable assignments.

prolog-resolution-ex2.png

Finally, let's look at a list predicate.

member(X, [X|_]).
member(X, [_|T]) :- member(X, T).

This is familiar to us from the Prolog notes. When we query with member(X, [a, b, c]) we get that X = a.

prolog-resolution-ex3.png

When we query with member(d, [a, b, c]) we get failure.

prolog-resolution-ex4.png

Much of these notes were adapted from Learn Prolog Now!, a free online textbook.

Intro to AI material by Joshua Eckroth is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License. Source code for this website available at GitHub.